Crime and Court news / Foreign relations

Marines case, Italy bluffs with India and loses


Italy has sent back to India her marines accused by the latter country of shooting some fisherman while on anti-piracy duty on an Italian merchant ship.

The Indian Supreme Court had authorized the marines to go home temporarily in order to vote in the last general elections. After their comeback the Italian Government, suddenly, had announced that they were not going back to India.

The Indian reaction had been exceptionally harsh. The Italian Ambassador in New Delhi, who had signed an affidavit with a personal pledge for the marines’ return, had been forbidden to leave India and was at risk of being indicted for contempt of the Court. According to the Indian Supreme Court, he was not entitled to diplomatic immunity since he had freely taken part in a local judicial proceeding. Probably, other measures of retaliation were also threatened.

Italy, with a weak economy and without a Government, got only a very lukewarm support from the European Union, with High Representative for Foreign Affairs Baroness Catherine Ashton even stating that the EU was not a part in the dispute and therefore not interfering in it.

In the end, yesterday the Interministerial Committee for the Security of the Republic decided that the marines had to be sent back to India, which was done with a hastily arranged Air Force flight. According to press sources, it took five hours to the Government to convince the two soldiers to board the plane.

The U-turn by the Government was harshly criticized by the Parliament (in particular by the right-wing parties) and by the Armed Forced trade unions (soldiers are allowed limited trade union representation in Italy). The Government has been summoned by the Parliament to report; the hearing is scheduled for Tuesday.


4 thoughts on “Marines case, Italy bluffs with India and loses

  1. Pingback: Berlusconi rallies supporters and raises the stakes | Italian Insight

  2. Pingback: Marines case takes drama tool on Monti Government | Italian Insight

  3. Pingback: Italian marines case: what the law says | Italian Insight

  4. Pingback: Marines case, Italy gets involuntary help from international partners | Italian Insight

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s